Support BMG PAC!
About BMG PAC
Make a secure credit card contribution using Google Checkout:
$
Or send a check to BMG PAC, PO Box 877, Medford, MA 02155.
View BMG PAC's latest disclosure report


Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?



FREE COPY OF BOB'S BOOK Barack Obama for Beginners to every 50th Facebook Friend!
BMG on Facebook

About
About us
Rules of the road - please read!
Formatting and multimedia tips
Email us
RSS feed

BMG TRAFFIC REPORT
Blue Mass. Swag
Creative Commons License

Event Calendar
February 2010
(view month)
S M T W R F S
* 01 02 03 04 05 06
07 08 09 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 * * * * * *
<< (add event) >>

Active Users
Currently 29 user(s) logged on.

Search




Advanced Search


Blog Roll
Massachusetts Left
.08 Acres
Below Boston
Berkshires Blog
Blue News Tribune
Chimes at Midnight
Eisenthal Report
Granby 01033
Health Care for All
Left in Lowell
MA lefty blogs
Marry in Mass.
Mass Engagement
Massachusetts Liberal
Michael Forbes-Wilcox
My Dedham
Progressive Mass.
Quriltai on the Shore
Ryan's Take
Someday I Will
ShrewsBuried
Talking Stoneham
The Fray
Universal hub

Differently-Winged
John Daley
Mass. Pro-Life
No Looking Backwards
Peter Porcupine
Pundit Review
Red Mass Group
Scaling the Hill 2010

Mass. Media
David S. Bernstein
Cambridge politics
CommonWealth Unbound
Globe bloggers
Herald bloggers
Hub Blog
Jon Keller
MassBeacon
Media Nation (Dan Kennedy)
Open Media Boston
Adam Reilly
Toll Talk (Mary Connaughton)
Weekly Dig Blog

Legal
ACS Blog
Balkinization
Election law
How Appealing
SCOTUSblog
Volokh Conspiracy

General
Accountable Strategies
Billionaires for Bush
Blue Works Better
Crooks and Liars
Daily Howler
Daily Kos
Democracy Arsenal
Eschaton (Atrios)
Glenn Greenwald
Grist (environment blog)
Hullabaloo (Digby)
LiberalOasis
MyDD
Oliver Willis
Pandagon
Political Animal
Political Critic
Political Wire
Poor Man
Progressive Blog Digest
Real Climate
Senate Guru
Swing State Project
Tapped
Talking Points Memo
Think Progress
Truth and Progress
Turn Maine Blue
Wonkette

www.BlueMassGroup.com

Bernstein debunks Politico story on Romney marching with King

by: David

Sun Dec 23, 2007 at 00:00:02 AM EST


David Bernstein has delivered again.  You'll recall, no doubt, that a story in the Politico recently claimed that George Romney actually did (literally, not figuratively) "march with" Martin Luther King, Jr. -- after all, two "eyewitnesses" said so.  And some outfit called "Politics1" picked up the story and declared that "Mitt Romney told the truth when he claimed this week that his father had marched for civil rights with Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.  The Politico reports eyewitnesses stepped forward to verify that then-Michigan Governor George Romney walked side-by-side with King in a 1963 civil rights march in Grosse Pointe, Michigan."

False.  George Romney did indeed participate in a 1963 civil rights march in Grosse Pointe.  But King wasn't there.  He was in New Jersey.  Here's Bernstein:

Then-governor George Romney did indeed march in Grosse Pointe, on Saturday, June 29, 1963, but Martin Luther King Jr. was not there; he was in New Brunswick, New Jersey, addressing the closing session of the annual New Jersey AFL-CIO labor institute at Rutgers University.

Those facts are indisputable, and quite frankly, the campaign must have known the women's story would eventually be debunked -- few people's every daily movement has been as closely tracked and documented as King's. As I write this, I am looking at an article from page E8 of the June 30, 1963 Chicago Tribune, which discusses both events (among other civil-rights actions of the previous day), clearly placing the two men hundreds of miles apart. I also have here the June 30, 1963 San Antonio News, which carries a photo and article about Romney at the Grosse Pointe march; and an AP story about King's speech in New Jersey.

A King researcher editing his letters from that time has stated definitively that the two men never marched together; Michigan and Grosse Pointe historians have stated definitively that King was not at the 1963 Grosse Pointe march; Michigan civil-rights participants of the time have concurred; so have those who worked for George Romney at the time.

Bernstein ascribes malevolent motives to the Romney campaign in all of this, and it's hard to disagree with him.

All of this evidence is important to present to the general public, but it is unnecessary for the Romney campaign -- it has been clear for some time that they know perfectly well that the two men never marched together.

Bear in mind that the Romney team has a substantial research team (and vast resources for outsourcing more). Bear in mind that the campaign has compiled vast documentation about the candidate's father, particularly his civil-rights activities, long before the Phoenix posed the question earlier this week. Bear in mind that the campaign has direct access to George Romney's materials and documents, his family members, his friends, his former staff, etc.

Believe me, they know the two men never marched together. This is an attempt to rewrite history. And even if it is a small rewriting, it is offensive.... Changing that history by mistake -- which is quite possibly how this began -- is unfortunate. Changing that history intentionally -- which is what the campaign is doing now -- is offensive.

I've said it before, and I'll say it again.  Mitt Romney is not worthy of the presidency.

David :: Bernstein debunks Politico story on Romney marching with King
Tags: , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
And the Democrats in the Senate... (0.00 / 0)
...pushed Bush into a hasty war in Iraq in 2002 - at least, that's the story if you listen to Karl Rove.  And the USA was founded on Christian principles, and there is no separation of church and state, etc, etc.

Historical revisionism seems to be habit-forming with this crowd...

Small dollar year round fundraising: PeanutButterPAC.org


Never ascribe to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence. (0.00 / 0)
Since these two ladies that came forward are mistaken is it so hard to believe that Mitt is also mistaken the same as they were?  Just because the campaign has access to certain resources doesn't mean they used them.

Wondered the same... too often (0.00 / 0)
I had the same question. I am a firm believer that the media and public are out to hang politicians without giving any benefit of the doubt.

There have, however, been so many examples of Romney getting caught in apparent lies, mistruths, dramatic reconstructions of his beliefs that my ability to think this all a media construct has worn thin.

I'd be willing to believe, for example, that Mitt Romney simply remembered this incorrectly, perhaps after being told the story so many times (maybe by the media?) But if that was the case why wouldn't he just say "Ooops. You know what? I really thought he did walk with MLK because among other things I read it in that book. Regardless, my father was a strong supporter of civil rights and MLK's message."

I'd be willing to believe that Romney had a change of heart on choice issues if he hadn't been such a strong supporter of choice, calling upon the memory of relatives who received back-alley abortions and his mother's staunch support of choice and his loud vocal support through races.

I'd be willing to believe he changed his mind on gay issues,... well, no, I actually don't believe him at all on this one.

There are so many areas where one needs to give him the benefit of the doubt in order to believe him that he's simply not believable any more.

Besides, "Give me the benefit of your doubt" is not a particularly good campaign slogan.


[ Parent ]
Has Romney EVER admitted publicly to making a mistake? (0.00 / 0)
Or being wrong?  Just asking.  Someone can give links to some public humility or admission of error, I am sure...

Deborah Sirotkin Butler
AmberPaw dot @aol.com

"Failure to plan is planning to fail."
Proverb


[ Parent ]
Handlers (0.00 / 0)
Aside from the honesty issue, I think this whole misstatement problem demonstrates that Romeny is a would-be leader who would rely entirely on "handlers," much like the current White House occupant.  There isn't a brain in his head, frankly, and he will spout any point of view that the polls tell him will gain him a supporter here or there.  He is a brainless puppet, not a President.

FRAUD (0.00 / 0)
The subject says it all.

So what? (0.00 / 0)
It's necessary to understand that whether or not Romney (either senior or junior) marched with Martin Luther King is not an important issue for most voters. The election of Bill Clinton demonstrates that issues like this just don't count.

Truthiness. (0.00 / 0)
This episode has really demonstrated Romney's disregard for the truth.  Colbert's concept of "truthiness" is writ large in Romney's revisionist ramblings about virtually everything from the patently inhumane treatment of Seamus to this walking-with-King tripe.

The man does not respect the truth in any meaningful way, as the sentient citizens of Massachusetts have discovered.  How on earth can a such an individual be trusted with the Presidency of the United States?  The notion is positively ludicrous.  

 


More proof they never marched together: (6.00 / 1)
I posted this to daily kos:

In the the did so/did not of whether former Michigan governor George Romney ever marched with Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., the Politico has now reported that on account of an alleged eye-witness statement, King and Romney were seen marching hand-in-hand in the streets of Grosse Pointe, Michigan, in the summer of 1963.  The problem is that it never happened--at least not as the alleged eye-witness, Shirley Bashore, claims.  The Politico reports:

Shirley Basore, 72, says she was sitting in the hairdresser's chair in wealthy Grosse Pointe, Mich., back in 1963 when a rumpus started and she discovered that Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and her governor, George Romney, were marching for civil rights - right past the window.

With the cape still around her neck, Basore went outside and joined the parade.

"They were hand in hand," recalled Basore, a former high-school English teacher. "They led the march. We all swung our hands, and they held their hands up above everybody else's."

The Politico article continues:

She remembered the late governor as "extremely handsome."

Until this week, that was just a vivid memory for a sweet retiree who now lives in Pompano Beach, Fla.

But Basore's memory became important this week when news accounts questioned the recollections of the late Michigan governor's son, Mitt Romney, the Republican presidential candidate and former Massachusetts governor.

The problem is that while Ms. Bashore may well have seen Gov. Romney march in Grosse Pointe on June 29, she did not see Dr. King.  A next-edition article from the Grosse Pointe News, the local paper, of July 4, 1963, ["Whites and Negroes Join in Demonstration Against Housing Discrimination"], does in fact mention Romney's surprise appearance and march in the Grosse Pointe demostration of June 29, 1963.  From the article:

Governor George Romney, an uninvited but warmly-welcomed guest, joined more than 600 NAACP demonstrators and white sympathizers in a march held in the Pointe Saturday afternoon, June 29[, 1963].
 

Speakers at the rally included Detroit NAACP president Edward Turner; Detroit NAACP executive secretary, Arthur L. Johnson; and Rev. Philip Stahl, president of the Grosse Pointe Ministers Association, but not Rev. King. A Grosse Pointe News archive of the July 4, 1963, edition [pdf] gives a detailed description of the march, the demonstration, and Romney's surprise appearance.

Important to this flap is the fact that the article, which continues to page 2 of the paper, never once mentions Martin Luthur King, Jr., as having attended either the march or the rally.

Additionally, the Detroit News photo archive of King's Detroit visit of June 23, 1963, where King did march six days prior to his alleged appearance in Grosse Pointe, the one Ms. Bashore cound not have seen, demonstrates that the closest King got to meeting the governor of Michigan was his meeting with former governor, John B. Swainson:

PHOTO 4  

See also photos 11 and 12, which show the Detroit march of June 23, 1963, and you will see that Romney was not in fact present:

PHOTO 11, PHOTO 12

The answer to all this confusion is that there were, in fact, two marches: one in Detroit on June 23, 1963, in which Dr. King marched, and one in Grosse Pointe, on June 29, 1963, in which Governor Romney marched, but neither of them attended the other event.

Ahhh, the vagaries of memory over time.


Politico? (5.00 / 1)
Isn't that a web site founded by fiction writer Roger L. Simon, who also founded PissPoorMedia (Pajamas Media) with millions of US$ supplied by right wing syncophants?




I support WWF


Political insider ad network Law blog ad network
Advertise Liberally









Powered by: SoapBlox